What proxy solicitation is
Proxy solicitation (委任状勧誘, formally 議決権の代理行使の勧誘) means asking other shareholders to let you, or someone else, exercise their votes at a general meeting on their behalf. Management can solicit proxies; so can a shareholder pushing its own resolutions, or one trying to defeat the company's.
For shares listed on a Japanese exchange, Article 194 of the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act (FIEA) says no one may solicit proxies in breach of the rules set by Cabinet Order. The detail is in Articles 36-2 to 36-6 of the FIEA Enforcement Order and in the Cabinet Office Ordinance on Solicitation of Proxies for Listed Shares (上場株式の議決権の代理行使の勧誘に関する内閣府令, the "Proxy Ordinance" here). The Proxy Ordinance took effect on April 1, 2003, replacing a 1948 rule of the Securities and Exchange Commission (証券取引委員会規則第13号).
The Companies Act: voting through a proxy
- A shareholder may vote through a proxy. The shareholder or the proxy must give the company a document proving the authority, the proxy form (委任状); with the company's consent this can be provided electronically instead (Companies Act, Article 310(1) and (3)).
- Authority must be granted separately for each meeting (Article 310(2)).
- If the shareholder has agreed to receive convocation notices electronically, the company may not refuse electronic proof of authority without good reason (Article 310(4)).
- The company may limit the number of proxies who can attend the meeting (Article 310(5)).
- Proxy documents must be kept at the head office for three months from the meeting date. Shareholders may ask to inspect or copy them, stating their reason; the company may refuse only where the request is not for securing or exercising the shareholder's rights, is meant to obstruct the business or harm shareholders' common interests, is made to pass on what is learned to a third party for profit, or comes from someone who has done that within the past two years (Article 310(6) to (8)).
The FIEA rules: what a solicitor must hand over
- Proxy form and reference documents: when soliciting, the solicitor (勧誘者) must give each person solicited a proxy form and a reference document (参考書類) containing the matters the Proxy Ordinance prescribes (Enforcement Order, Article 36-2(1)).
- Electronic delivery: with the recipient's prior consent, given in writing or electronically after being told the type and content of the electronic method, the solicitor may provide the contents electronically, which counts as delivery. If the recipient later says they no longer want electronic delivery, the solicitor must stop unless the recipient consents again (Article 36-2(2) to (4)).
- Form of the proxy: the form must have a box for each resolution in which the shareholder marks approval or disapproval. A separate abstain box is allowed (Proxy Ordinance, Article 43).
When the rules do not apply
Articles 36-2 to 36-5 of the Enforcement Order do not apply in three cases (Article 36-6):
- The solicitor is neither the issuer nor one of its officers, and fewer than 10 people are solicited.
- The solicitation is made through an advertisement in a daily newspaper that carries current affairs, and the advertisement shows only the issuer's name, the reason for the advertisement, the matters for the meeting and where the proxy form and related materials can be obtained.
- A person holding shares in another's name solicits that nominee for the votes on those shares. People solicited in this way are not counted toward the 10 in the first case.
What the reference documents must say
The basic contents depend on who is soliciting (Proxy Ordinance, Article 1(1)):
| Solicitor | Basic contents of the reference documents |
| The issuer or its officers | That the issuer or an officer is soliciting; the resolutions; the reasons for them (for resolutions proposed by the directors, including anything that must be explained at the meeting); and a summary of any investigation results that statutory auditors or similar bodies must report to the meeting under the Companies Act |
| Anyone else, such as a shareholder | The resolutions; the solicitor's name and address |
- Resolution-by-resolution items: the Proxy Ordinance then lists what must be stated for each kind of resolution, such as electing or removing directors and statutory auditors, pay, mergers, share exchanges and reverse stock splits. Articles 2 to 20 cover solicitation by or for the company; Articles 21 to 38 cover solicitation by others. For a director election, for example, the company side must give the candidates' careers, shareholdings, any special interest in the company, and any liability-limitation agreement, indemnification agreement or D&O insurance (Article 2); another solicitor need only give the candidates' names, dates of birth and careers, significant concurrent positions, any special interest, and the current position and duties of a sitting director (Article 21).
- Indemnification and D&O insurance: these items came in with the Companies Act amendments that took effect on March 1, 2021, and apply only to agreements made on or after that date (Cabinet Office Ordinance No. 5 of 2021, supplementary provisions, Article 9).
- Shareholder resolutions: where the company side solicits on a shareholder's resolution, the documents must say that a shareholder proposed it and give the board's opinion and the reasons the shareholder supplied, among other things (Article 39). Where someone else solicits on it, they must say that a shareholder proposed it and give the reasons and the items prescribed for that kind of resolution (Article 40). For the proposal rules themselves, see Shareholder proposals at Japanese companies.
- What can be left out: items already in the meeting reference documents (株主総会参考書類), the voting form (議決権行使書面) or other materials for the same meeting, or provided electronically, need not be repeated, but the reference documents must say they exist. The same goes for items covered by the company's electronic provision of meeting materials (電子提供措置), with the prescribed statement (Article 1(2) and (3)).
- Beyond the required items, a solicitor may add anything it considers useful to shareholders deciding whether to grant a proxy (Article 1(7)).
Filing copies, misleading materials and penalties
- Copies: after delivering the proxy form and reference documents, the solicitor must immediately file copies with the Commissioner of the Financial Services Agency (Enforcement Order, Article 36-3). The power to receive them is delegated to the Director-General of the Local Finance Bureau for the solicitor's head office or main office (the Fukuoka Local Finance Branch Bureau within its area); for non-residents, the Kanto Local Finance Bureau (Article 43-11).
- When no copy is needed: for the same meeting, where every shareholder entitled to vote has received the meeting reference documents (or these were provided through electronic provision, or for an annual meeting were included in a securities report filed on EDINET) and has also received the voting form (or it was provided through electronic provision) (Proxy Ordinance, Article 44).
- Misleading materials: no one may solicit using a proxy form, reference document or other material that contains a false statement on an important matter, or omits an important matter that must be stated or an important fact needed to avoid misunderstanding (Enforcement Order, Article 36-4).
- Shareholders' right to the documents: where proxies are solicited by or for the company, a shareholder may ask the company for the reference documents on paying a fee the company sets (Article 36-5).
- Penalties: breaching FIEA Article 194 carries a fine of up to 300,000 yen (Article 205-2-3(1)(ii)). Where a representative or employee commits the breach in the course of a company's business, the company is fined as well (Article 207(1)(vi)).
How it relates to postal voting
- A company with 1,000 or more shareholders entitled to vote must, as a rule, let shareholders who do not attend vote in writing (Companies Act, Article 298(2)). It must then send the meeting reference documents and a voting form with the convocation notice (Article 301(1)), and votes cast in writing count as votes of shareholders present (Article 311(2)).
- The exception: a listed company need not offer postal voting if, with the convocation notice, it sends a proxy form under the FIEA to all such shareholders, soliciting them to have a third party vote for them (Article 298(2) proviso; Ordinance for Enforcement of the Companies Act, Article 64).
This page explains the framework only. For any particular solicitation, rely on the actual reference documents, the convocation notice and the company's own disclosures. For how meetings work in general, see How Japanese shareholder meetings work. Kabuto's other company stories are under Other, each linked to the TDnet original.
Sources