What a shareholder proposal is
A shareholder proposal (株主提案) is a shareholder putting their own agenda item or resolution before the general meeting. The Companies Act splits this into three rights:
- The right to add an agenda item (Article 303): asking the directors to make a matter, such as "election of directors" or "amendment of the articles", a subject of the meeting.
- The right to move a resolution (Article 304): putting forward a specific resolution, such as named candidates or article wording, at the meeting itself on a matter already on the agenda.
- The right to have the resolution circulated (Article 305): asking the directors to send other shareholders an outline of the resolution the shareholder intends to move, in practice by including it in the convocation notice.
All three apply only to matters on which the proposing shareholder can vote. For how meetings work in general, see How Japanese shareholder meetings work.
Who can propose, and by when
| Right | Company without a board | Company with a board |
| Adding an agenda item (Art. 303) | Any shareholder | Holding 1% or more of all shareholders' voting rights, or 300 or more votes, continuously for six months; request at least eight weeks before the meeting |
| Moving a resolution at the meeting (Art. 304) | Any shareholder | Any shareholder (on matters already on the agenda) |
| Circulating the resolution (Art. 305) | Any shareholder; request at least eight weeks before the meeting | Same holding test as Art. 303; request at least eight weeks before the meeting |
- The articles may lower the percentage, the vote count, the six months and the eight weeks.
- A company with a board that is not a public company has no six-month requirement; holding is enough (Articles 303(3) and 305(2)). A public company (公開会社) is one whose articles do not make all of its shares transfer-restricted (Article 2(v)).
- In calculating the 1%, the votes of shareholders who cannot vote on the matter are left out of the total (Articles 303(4) and 305(3)).
Book-entry shares: an individual shareholder notice comes first
Book-entry shares (振替株式) are shares whose ownership is recorded in the books of a transfer institution under the Act on Book-Entry Transfer of Company Bonds, Shares, etc. Article 147(4) of that act calls shareholder rights other than those fixed by a record date 少数株主権等 ("minority shareholder rights, etc."). When such rights are exercised over book-entry shares, Companies Act Article 130(1), the rule that a shareholder relies on the shareholder register against the company, does not apply (Article 154(1)).
- The shareholder applies through the broker or other institution holding their account (the 直近上位機関) to the book-entry transfer institution, which notifies the issuer without delay of the shareholder's name, address, holdings and related details (Article 154(3) and (4)). This is the 個別株主通知, the individual shareholder notice.
- The rights may be exercised only until the end of a period, set by Cabinet Order, that starts with the notice (Article 154(2)). That period is four weeks (Enforcement Order of the act, Article 40).
When a proposal can be turned away
- Unlawful or contrary to the articles: such a resolution may not be moved at the meeting (Article 304, proviso), and the circulation right does not apply to it (Article 305(6)).
- Resubmission within three years: if a substantially identical resolution failed to win 10% (or a lower figure set in the articles) of all shareholders' voting rights at a meeting, it may not be moved or circulated for three years from that day. Shareholders who cannot vote on the resolution are left out of the total.
- More than 10 resolutions (Article 305(4)): at a company with a board, if one shareholder intends to put forward more than 10 resolutions, the circulation right does not apply to the excess. The cap was added by Act No. 70 of 2019 and took effect on March 1, 2021; Article 305 as of December 1, 2020 had no such limit.
How the 10 are counted:
- Resolutions to elect directors, accounting advisors, statutory auditors (監査役) or the accounting auditor count as one, however many candidates there are; resolutions to dismiss them likewise count as one, as does a resolution not to reappoint the accounting auditor.
- Two or more amendments to the articles count as one if voting on them differently could produce contradictory results.
- The directors decide which resolutions are the excess; if the shareholder ranked their resolutions in the request, the directors follow that order (Article 305(5)).
The convocation notice and reference documents
- Convocation notice: after a request under Article 305, the outline of the resolution goes into the written or electronic convocation notice (Article 305(1)). For companies using electronic provision of meeting materials, the outline is one of the items provided electronically (Article 325-3(1)(iv)); a company that issues book-entry shares must provide for electronic provision in its articles (Book-Entry Transfer Act, Article 159-2).
- Reference documents (Ordinance for Enforcement of the Companies Act, Article 93): for a shareholder's resolution they must state (1) that a shareholder proposed it; (2) the board's opinion on it, if the board has one; (3) the reasons for the proposal that the shareholder gave the company with the request; (4) for elections, the candidate information the shareholder gave; and (5) for an acquisition of class shares subject to a wholesale call or a reverse stock split, the related details the shareholder gave.
- What may be left out or summarized: reasons that are clearly false, or that appear intended solely to damage someone's reputation or to insult, need not be included; nor does candidate or similar information that is clearly false. Where items (3) to (5) are too long to reproduce in full (including where they exceed a length the company has set), a summary may be given instead.
- Proposals to the same effect: where two or more shareholders put forward resolutions to the same effect, the resolutions and the board's opinion need not be set out separately, but the documents must say that more than one shareholder proposed it; the reasons need not be set out separately either.
How this differs from demanding a meeting
A proposal puts a resolution into a meeting the company calls. A shareholder who wants a separate meeting uses the demand to convene (招集請求, Article 297): shareholders holding 3% or more of all voting rights continuously for six months (the articles may relax both) may demand that the directors call a meeting, stating the subject and the reason. If the company does not start the convocation process without delay, or does not send a notice for a meeting held within eight weeks of the demand, the shareholder may call the meeting themselves with the court's permission.
Disclosures you will see on TDnet
| Common title wording | Meaning |
| 株主提案に対する当社取締役会の意見について | The board's opinion on a shareholder proposal (support or opposition, with reasons) |
| 株主提案に対する当社取締役会意見の概要 | A summary of the board's opinion |
| 臨時株主総会の開催及び株主提案に対する当社取締役会意見に関するお知らせ | The company calls an extraordinary meeting and gives its opinion on shareholder proposals at the same time |
| 株主による臨時株主総会の招集請求に関するお知らせ | A shareholder has demanded an extraordinary meeting |
| 議決権行使の結果に関するお知らせ | Voting results |
This page explains the framework only. For any particular company, rely on its own disclosures and convocation notice for what was proposed, the board's view and the vote. Kabuto's other company stories are under Other, each linked to the TDnet original.
Sources