What a governance structure is
The Companies Act calls the persons and bodies that decide, execute and oversee a company's business its organs (機関). Every stock company must have at least one director (取締役). Whether it also has a board of directors, an accounting advisor, company auditors (監査役, kansayaku), a board of company auditors, an accounting auditor (会計監査人), an audit and supervisory committee, or a nominating committee and the other committees is set in its articles of incorporation (Companies Act Article 326). The combination a company chooses is its governance structure (機関設計).
For listed companies the choice is narrow. Rule 437 of the Tokyo Stock Exchange's Securities Listing Regulations requires every domestic listed company to have a board of directors; one of a board of company auditors, an audit and supervisory committee, or a nominating committee, etc.; and an accounting auditor. The interpretive guidance to Basic Principle 4 of the TSE's Corporate Governance Code says listed companies usually choose one of the three main structures in the Companies Act (company with a board of company auditors, company with a nominating committee, etc., company with an audit and supervisory committee), and that whichever they choose, what matters is making each body work in substance.
The three structures at a glance
| Item | Company with a board of company auditors (監査役会設置会社) | Company with an audit and supervisory committee (監査等委員会設置会社) | Company with a nominating committee, etc. (指名委員会等設置会社) |
| Who audits | The board of company auditors: at least three kansayaku, at least half of them outside kansayaku (Article 335(3)). Kansayaku are not directors | The audit and supervisory committee. Its members are directors (Article 399-2(2)), at least three, a majority of them outside directors (Article 331(6)) | The audit committee, alongside the nominating and compensation committees. Each committee has at least three members, chosen by the board from among the directors, a majority of them outside directors (Article 400) |
| Who runs the business | The representative director and other directors | The representative director and other directors. The representative director is chosen from directors who are not committee members (Article 399-13(3)) | Executive officers (執行役, Article 418), elected by the board; they may also be directors (Article 402(2) and (6)) |
| Director term | Two years, which may be shortened (Article 332(1)) | One year for directors who are not committee members; two years for committee members, which cannot be shortened (Article 332(3) and (4)) | One year (Article 332(6)). Executive officers also serve one year (Article 402(7)) |
| Kansayaku | Yes, forming the board of company auditors, with four-year terms (Article 336(1)) | Not allowed (Article 327(4)) | Not allowed (Article 327(4)) |
| Accounting auditor | Required for public companies that are large companies (Article 328(1)); listed companies also need one under Listing Rule 437 | Required (Article 327(5)) | Required (Article 327(5)) |
All three must have a board of directors (Article 327(1)). A large company (大会社) is one whose latest balance sheet shows stated capital of ¥500 million or more, or total liabilities of ¥20 billion or more (Article 2(vi)). For appointing and changing the accounting auditor, see Japan auditor changes.
Company with a board of company auditors
- Kansayaku: they audit the directors' performance of their duties and prepare an audit report, and may at any time ask directors and employees to report on the business and investigate the company's operations and assets (Article 381). They cannot also be a director, employee or similar of the company or its subsidiaries (Article 335(2)). They must attend board meetings and speak when they think it necessary (Article 383(1)), but the board consists of all the directors (Article 362(1)), and kansayaku are not among them.
- Board of company auditors: made up of all the kansayaku, it prepares the audit report, selects and removes full-time kansayaku, and sets audit policy and similar matters; decisions on audit policy and similar matters cannot stop an individual kansayaku from exercising their own powers (Article 390(2)). It must select full-time kansayaku from among its members (Article 390(3)).
- What the board cannot delegate: decisions on important business matters, such as disposing of or acquiring important assets, large borrowings, appointing and removing important employees, and setting up or changing branches and other important organizations, cannot be delegated to individual directors (Article 362(4)).
- Outside directors: a company with a board of company auditors that is a public company and a large company, and must file annual securities reports under the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act, must have an outside director (Article 327-2). This came from Companies Act amendments promulgated on December 11, 2019 (Act No. 70 of 2019) that took effect on March 1, 2021. Before then, if such a company had no outside director, its directors had to explain at the annual shareholders' meeting why having one would not be appropriate.
Company with an audit and supervisory committee
- Committee members are directors: unlike kansayaku, audit and supervisory committee members are directors themselves (Article 399-2(2)). They cannot also be executive directors, employees or similar of the company or its subsidiaries (Article 331(3)).
- Separate elections and separate pay: shareholders elect committee-member directors separately from other directors (Article 329(2)), and set their pay separately (Article 361(2)). Before putting a proposal to elect committee members to the shareholders' meeting, the directors need the committee's consent (Article 344-2(1)). Removing a committee member takes a special resolution of shareholders (Article 309(2)(vii)).
- What the committee does: it audits the directors' performance of their duties and prepares an audit report; decides the content of proposals to the shareholders' meeting to appoint, remove or not reappoint the accounting auditor; and decides its opinion on the election, removal, resignation and pay of the other directors (Article 399-2(3)). A committee member chosen by the committee states that opinion at the shareholders' meeting (Article 342-2(4) and Article 361(6)).
- Delegation is possible: as a rule, the board cannot delegate decisions on important business matters to directors (Article 399-13(4)). But if a majority of the directors are outside directors, the board may delegate them by resolution (Article 399-13(5)), and the articles may allow the board to delegate all or part of them by resolution (Article 399-13(6)). The matters listed in paragraph (5), such as the content of proposals to the shareholders' meeting and merger agreements that need shareholder approval, still cannot be delegated. An articles provision under paragraph (6) is also registered (Article 911(3)(xxii)(c)).
Company with a nominating committee, etc.
- Three committees: the nominating committee decides the content of proposals to the shareholders' meeting to elect and remove directors; the audit committee audits the executive officers' and directors' performance of their duties, prepares an audit report, and decides the content of proposals to appoint, remove or not reappoint the accounting auditor; the compensation committee decides each executive officer's and director's individual pay (Article 404). Audit committee members cannot also be executive officers, executive directors or similar of the company or its subsidiaries (Article 400(4)).
- Executive officers: there must be at least one, elected by board resolution (Article 402(1) and (2)). They run the business and make the business decisions the board delegates to them (Article 418). Directors cannot also be employees of the company (Article 331(4)), but executive officers may also be directors (Article 402(6)). The company is represented by a representative executive officer; see Japan representative director changes.
- The board: it decides the basic management policy, the internal control framework and similar matters, and oversees the executive officers and directors (Article 416(1) and (2)). It may delegate business decisions to executive officers by resolution, except the matters listed in Article 416(4), which include the content of proposals to the shareholders' meeting (other than proposals to elect or remove directors and the accounting auditor, which the committees decide), electing and removing committee members and executive officers, selecting and removing the representative executive officer, and merger agreements that need shareholder approval.
Letting the board set dividends and buybacks (Article 459)
A company with an accounting auditor may provide in its articles that the board decides matters such as acquiring treasury shares (other than from specific shareholders) and paying dividends from surplus (Article 459(1)), if it meets both of these conditions:
- Directors' terms (in a company with an audit and supervisory committee, only directors who are not committee members) are no longer than one year.
- It is not a company that has kansayaku but no board of company auditors.
Companies with an audit and supervisory committee or a nominating committee, etc. already have one-year terms by law; a company with a board of company auditors has to shorten directors' terms to one year to qualify. The provision is effective only when the financial statements for the latest fiscal year meet the requirements set by Ministry of Justice ordinance (Article 459(2)). On TDnet, buyback filings whose titles cite 会社法第459条第1項の規定による定款の定めに基づく自己株式の取得 are board decisions under such a provision; those citing 会社法第165条第2項 are board decisions, under the articles, to buy on the market or by tender offer. See How Japanese buybacks work.
Switching structures: amending the articles
- Special resolution of shareholders: an audit and supervisory committee or a nominating committee, etc. is set up in the articles (Article 326(2)). The articles are amended by shareholder resolution (Article 466), and this is a special resolution: shareholders holding a majority of the voting rights must be present (the articles may lower this to one-third or more), and two-thirds or more of the votes present must be in favor (Article 309(2)(xi)).
- Terms end together: when an amendment that sets up or abolishes an audit and supervisory committee or a nominating committee, etc. takes effect, the sitting directors' terms end (Article 332(7)); setting one up also ends the kansayaku's terms (Article 336(4)(ii)); abolishing a nominating committee, etc. also ends the executive officers' terms (Article 402(8)). That is why transition filings often come with the new line-up of officers.
- TSE disclosure: when the body that makes business decisions decides to amend the articles, the company must disclose it immediately (Securities Listing Regulations Rule 402(1)(an)) unless the only reasons are wording changes following amendments to laws, a move of the head office, or other reasons the TSE treats as having a minor effect. The filing gives the purpose, the content and the schedule, with a comparison of old and new wording. Whether or not disclosure is required, the amended articles must be sent to the TSE without delay.
- Registration: a company with a board of company auditors registers that fact and which kansayaku are outside kansayaku; a company with an audit and supervisory committee registers that fact, the names of committee-member and other directors, and which directors are outside directors; a company with a nominating committee, etc. registers that fact, which directors are outside directors, the names of committee members and executive officers, and the name and address of the representative executive officer (Article 911(3)(xviii), (xxii) and (xxiii)).
- CG report: the TSE's corporate governance report comes in three formats, for companies with kansayaku, with an audit and supervisory committee, and with a nominating committee, etc., matching the company's current structure. See Japan's Corporate Governance Code.
Outside directors and independent officers
- Definition of outside director (Article 2(xv)): not an executive director, executive officer, employee or similar (業務執行取締役等) of the company or its subsidiaries, and not one at any time in the ten years before taking office; a person who was a director, accounting advisor or kansayaku of the company or a subsidiary (other than as one of those executive roles) at some point in those ten years must also not have held those executive roles in the ten years before taking that earlier post. The person also cannot be a parent company or similar that is an individual, a director, executive officer or employee of the parent company or similar, an executive director or similar of a sister company, or the spouse or a relative within the second degree of a director, executive officer or important employee of the company or of a parent company or similar that is an individual. Outside kansayaku are defined in Article 2(xvi).
- TSE: at least one outside director: Listing Rule 437-2 requires every domestic listed company to have at least one outside director, whatever its structure. A company without one is in breach and can face the public announcement and other measures under Rule 508.
- Independent officers: an outside director or outside kansayaku with no risk of a conflict of interest with ordinary shareholders. Listing Rule 436-2 requires at least one, and the company must file an independent officer notification (独立役員届出書) with the TSE; when its content changes, a new notification is in principle due two weeks before the change (Enforcement Rules 436-2). Having at least one independent officer among the directors is a best-efforts duty (Listing Rule 445-4).
- Corporate Governance Code: Principle 4-10 says Prime Market companies should have independent outside directors making up at least one-third of the board, and companies on other markets at least two. Principle 4-7 says a company with a board of company auditors or an audit and supervisory committee whose independent outside directors are not a majority of the board should set up independent nominating and compensation committees made up mainly of independent outside directors. These are voluntary bodies, not the statutory committees of a company with a nominating committee, etc. At Prime companies, independent outside directors should as a rule be a majority of each committee.
TDnet filings to watch
| Title contains | Meaning |
| 監査等委員会設置会社への移行に関するお知らせ | The company decides to become a company with an audit and supervisory committee, which needs shareholders to approve amending the articles |
| 監査等委員会設置会社への移行及び役員人事に関するお知らせ | The transition plus director nominations for the new structure |
| 監査等委員会設置会社への移行に伴う定款一部変更に関するお知らせ | Amendments to the articles needed for the transition: purpose, content, schedule |
| 指名委員会等設置会社への移行に関するお知らせ | The company decides to become a company with a nominating committee, etc. |
| 定款変更に関するお知らせ | A general amendment to the articles |
| 独立役員の指定に関するお知らせ | Designation of independent officers |
| 自己株式の取得状況に関するお知らせ(会社法第459条第1項の規定による定款の定めに基づく自己株式の取得) | Progress of a buyback decided by the board under an Article 459 provision in the articles |
Kabuto's people stories are under People, each linked to the TDnet original.
Sources
- 会社法 第2条第6号, 第10号-第12号, 第15号, 第16号 / 第309条第2項第7号, 第11号 / 第326条 / 第327条 / 第327条の2 / 第328条 / 第329条 / 第331条第3項-第6項 / 第332条 / 第335条 / 第336条 / 第342条の2 / 第344条の2 / 第361条第2項, 第6項 / 第362条 / 第381条 / 第383条 / 第390条 / 第399条の2 / 第399条の13 / 第400条 / 第402条 / 第404条 / 第416条 / 第418条 / 第459条 / 第466条 / 第911条第3項第18号, 第22号, 第23号(e-Gov 法令 API: 2026-08-12 施行分が現行)
- 会社法 改正履歴(e-Gov 法令 API: 令和元年法律第70号 2019-12-11 公布, 2021-03-01 施行)
- 会社法 2021-02-28 時点(2020-12-01 施行分) 第327条の2(社外取締役を置いていない場合の理由の開示)(e-Gov 法令 API asof=2021-02-28 / 法令検索 時点版)
- 東京証券取引所 会社情報適時開示ガイドブック(2026年7月版): 36. 定款の変更(上場規程第402条第1号 an) / 企業行動規範 (6) 独立役員の確保(第436条の2) / (10) 上場内国会社の機関(第437条) / (11) 社外取締役の確保(第437条の2) / 望まれる事項 (3) 取締役である独立役員の確保(第445条の4) / CG コード 基本原則4 解釈指針, 原則4-7, 原則4-10 / CG 報告書 記載要領 II 1.(1) 組織形態, (2) 5 社外取締役の選任状況
- TDnet 適時開示情報閲覧サービス: 各社の 監査等委員会設置会社への移行 / 監査等委員会設置会社への移行及び役員人事 / 監査等委員会設置会社への移行に伴う定款一部変更 / 指名委員会等設置会社への移行 / 定款変更 / 独立役員の指定 に関するお知らせ, 自己株式の取得状況に関するお知らせ(会社法第459条第1項の規定による定款の定めに基づく自己株式の取得)(2026-09 至 2026-11)