What these filings are
When a Japanese listed company finds accounting fraud or other misconduct (or suspects it), a familiar sequence appears on TDnet: an internal investigation committee (社内調査委員会) or a third-party committee (第三者委員会) is set up, the earnings release is postponed, the company applies to extend the deadline for its annual or semi-annual report, it receives the investigation report, restates past results, and publishes measures to prevent a recurrence. Some of these steps are required by law or by Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE) rules. Others follow principles issued by Japan Exchange Regulation (JPX-R), which are not binding. This page keeps the two apart.
JPX-R's principles for responding to scandals (2016)
JPX-R issued the Principles for Responding to Corporate Scandals (上場会社における不祥事対応のプリンシプル) on February 24, 2016. A scandal here means a serious violation of law or other wrongful or improper conduct. There are four principles:
- Find the root cause: set a scope of investigation wide enough to do the job, go beyond listing surface events and chains of cause and effect to bring out the background, establish the facts firmly, and build the investigation set-up best suited to that. Qualified people, including independent officers, should take the lead in self-correction.
- Keep a third-party committee independent, neutral and expert: where there are substantial doubts about the effectiveness of internal control or the trustworthiness of management, where the damage to corporate value is large, or where the case is complex or has serious social impact, a third-party committee is a strong option. Its independence, neutrality and expertise need careful attention, including how members are chosen, and the committee format must not be used to dress up a quick, inadequate investigation as objective.
- Design effective prevention measures and carry them out quickly: changing the organization chart or internal rules is not enough. The measures must show up in day-to-day operations, and the company should check that they are being used as intended and have taken hold.
- Disclose promptly and accurately: from the moment the facts are grasped through to the implementation of prevention measures, disclose as needed, explaining the background, the substance of the case and the company's view with care, so the process is transparent.
JPX-R states that the principles, unlike laws and exchange rules, do not bind listed companies across the board, and that no measures will be taken against a company without a basis in the rules even if it falls short of them.
The principles for preventing scandals (2018)
On March 30, 2018, JPX-R added the Principles for Preventing Corporate Scandals (上場会社における不祥事予防のプリンシプル), which focus on prevention and are meant to work alongside the response principles as "two wheels of a car." The six principles are: grasp the real state of compliance, not just the formal one; fulfil duties with a sense of mission; two-way communication; spot the seeds of misconduct and act quickly; management control that runs through the whole group (overseas and acquired subsidiaries are named); and a sense of responsibility across the supply chain. These too are principles-based guidance, and falling short of them does not lead to adverse action without a basis in the listing rules.
JPX-R also explains the limits of its role. It can decide on adverse action under the listing rules for cases that directly threaten the capital market, such as false statements in annual securities reports, improper disclosure and breaches of the Corporate Code of Conduct. It is not in a position to act directly against misconduct committed in the course of business as such, where that misconduct does not breach the listing rules.
Duties under TSE rules
- Inquiries and investigation: when the TSE (or JPX-R, which carries out self-regulatory work on its behalf) makes an inquiry, the company must report accurately and immediately. Where the TSE considers it necessary for that report, the company must also carry out the necessary investigation and report the results (Listing Regulations Rule 415(1) and (2)). The TSE's guidebook says this is aimed at cases where doubts such as accounting fraud have arisen and no investigation has been done, or the scope or set-up of the investigation is inadequate. For what counts as a necessary investigation, it generally expects companies to refer to the response principles above and to the Japan Federation of Bar Associations' guidelines on third-party committees (企業等不祥事における第三者委員会ガイドライン).
- No dedicated "scandal" disclosure item: instead, the catch-all (basket) clause in Rule 402(2)(x) requires immediate disclosure of any important fact that would significantly affect investment decisions. The guidebook's benchmarks include an expected change in consolidated total assets of 30% of prior-year consolidated net assets, a change in consolidated net sales of 10%, or a change in consolidated ordinary profit or net income of 30%. A fact below the benchmarks must still be disclosed if it is material in substance. If the company recalculates its full-year forecast as a result, it may also have to file a forecast revision (see Earnings forecast revisions in Japan).
- Correcting results: a change or correction to an earnings release already published must be disclosed as a correction to the earnings release materials (決算発表資料の訂正; Rule 416). The guidebook asks companies to contact the TSE promptly when they expect to restate past years' results.
Extending the deadline for annual and semi-annual reports
Under the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act (FIEA), a domestic company must file its annual securities report within three months after the end of the fiscal year (Article 24(1)). A listed company's semi-annual report is due within a period set by cabinet order of up to 45 days after the half-year, or up to 60 days for banks and other businesses whose soundness must be secured (Article 24-5(1)). Both articles allow filing within a period approved in advance by the Prime Minister where there is an unavoidable reason the company cannot meet the deadline.
- The application: the company files an application with the Director-General of the Local Finance Bureau (or equivalent) stating the period it wants approved, the fiscal year-end, the reason approval is needed, and how it will make the approval, and any lapse or change in the reason, known to the public. The articles of incorporation and documents proving the reason are attached (Cabinet Office Ordinance on Disclosure of Corporate Affairs, Article 15-2(1) and (2); parallel provisions cover the semi-annual report). The bureau approves the application where it finds an unavoidable reason, and may change the period or revoke the approval going forward if the reason lapses or changes (Article 15-2(3) and (4)).
- TSE disclosure: the company must disclose immediately when it decides to file the application (Rule 402(1)(ak-2)), when approval is granted or refused (Rule 402(2)(u-2)), and when it does not expect to file by the statutory deadline, has failed to file by it, or files after such a notice (Rule 402(2)(u)). Once a notice that the company does not expect to file in time, or has missed the deadline, is made, the shares are designated as securities under supervision (confirmation) (監理銘柄(確認中); see Securities under supervision in Japan).
- Delisting criterion: failing to file the annual or semi-annual report with the audit or review report attached within one month after the statutory deadline is a delisting criterion. Where an extension was approved, the cut-off is the eighth day (excluding non-business days) after the approved period ends; where the delay is due to a natural disaster or other cause the company is not responsible for, it is three months after the deadline (Rule 601(1)(vii) and Enforcement Rules Rule 601(7)). For the report itself, see The annual securities report in Japan.
After the investigation: amendment reports, measures and delisting review
- Amendment reports: where an annual securities report or its attachments need correcting, the company files an amendment report (訂正報告書; FIEA Article 24-2(1), applying Article 7(1)).
- TSE measures: false statements in the annual securities report or similar filings, an adverse or disclaimer audit opinion, or a breach of the timely disclosure rules as found by the TSE can lead to designation as a security on special alert, a required improvement report, a public announcement or a listing agreement violation penalty (see Securities on special alert in Japan).
- Delisting: a false statement does not by itself mean automatic delisting. The criterion is a false statement in the annual securities report or similar filings where the TSE finds it clear that market order would be hard to maintain without delisting immediately, or an adverse opinion or a disclaimer of opinion in the audit report or similar that meets the same test (see Delisting in Japan).
TDnet filings to watch
| Common title wording | Meaning |
| 社内調査委員会の設置 / 第三者委員会の設置に関するお知らせ | An investigation committee is set up |
| 第三者委員会の委員の選任及び委嘱事項 | Committee members, the scope of the investigation and when results are expected to be disclosed |
| 決算発表の延期に関するお知らせ | The earnings release is postponed |
| 半期報告書の提出期限延長に係る承認申請書提出のお知らせ | The company decides to apply for a filing deadline extension |
| 提出期限延長に係る承認及び決算発表日のお知らせ | The extension is approved and a new results date is set |
| 第三者委員会の調査報告書受領及び今後の対応 | The investigation report is received, with next steps |
| 再発防止策の実施状況に関するお知らせ | Progress on prevention measures |
Filings about cyber incidents (不正アクセス, data leaks) often contain the word 不正 too, but they are usually not the accounting or legal-compliance investigations this page covers. This page explains the framework only and does not assess any company's case. Kabuto's stories of this kind are under Other, each linked to the TDnet original.
Sources