Fri, Nov 20, 2026中文About
Filings today 284 / Covered 15
Source: TDnet timely disclosures
Updated 11/20 20:30M&A / TOB 20 Guidance 7 Buybacks 11 Dividends 4 Capital 12 Earnings 16 People 3

Internal Control Reports in Japan (内部統制報告書): Material Weaknesses, the Four Possible Conclusions, Internal Control Audits, TSE Disclosure and the Standard Revised from April 2024

Last checked against the sources: 2026-11-11

What an internal control report is

Every fiscal year, a Japanese listed company must assess its internal control over financial reporting (財務報告に係る内部統制), write up the result as an internal control report (内部統制報告書), and file it together with its annual securities report (Financial Instruments and Exchange Act, or FIEA, Article 24-4-4(1)). A Cabinet Office Ordinance defines what is assessed as the system that ensures the company's financial reporting is properly prepared in accordance with laws and regulations (財務計算に関する書類その他の情報の適正性を確保するための体制に関する内閣府令, called the Internal Control Ordinance on this page, Article 3).

  • Who files: issuers of listed shares and similar securities (FIEA Enforcement Order Article 4-2-7). Other companies that file annual securities reports may file one voluntarily.
  • As of when: the last day of the fiscal year (Internal Control Ordinance Article 5).
  • Against what: the Business Accounting Council's standard for the assessment and audit of internal control over financial reporting ("the standard" on this page) and its implementation guidance (実施基準) (Internal Control Ordinance Article 1(5)). The system has applied to fiscal years beginning on or after April 1, 2008.
  • Public access: reports and their amendments are open to public inspection for five years (FIEA Article 25).

Internal control and material weaknesses

The standard defines internal control as a process, built into operations and carried out by everyone in the organization, that gives reasonable assurance of four objectives: effective and efficient operations, reliable reporting, compliance with the laws that apply to the business, and safeguarding of assets. It has six basic components: the control environment, risk assessment and response, control activities, information and communication, monitoring, and response to IT. The FIEA system is concerned only with the reliability of financial reporting.

  • Effective: designed and operated in line with an appropriate framework, with no material weakness (standard, II.1).
  • Material weakness (開示すべき重要な不備, literally a significant deficiency that must be disclosed): a deficiency in internal control over financial reporting that is highly likely to have a material effect on financial reporting (Internal Control Ordinance Article 2(x); standard, II.1).

To decide whether a deficiency is a material weakness, the implementation guidance requires looking at both amount and nature, in principle against the consolidated financial statements. Amount is judged as a ratio to consolidated total assets, net sales, profit before tax and so on, not applied uniformly. The guidance gives roughly 5% of consolidated profit before tax as an example, to be considered alongside materiality in the financial statement audit; if profit before tax becomes far smaller or negative, the ratio or measure can be changed. On nature, examples include items tied to the delisting criteria, financial covenants, related-party transactions and major shareholders.

How management assesses it

  • Company level first: in principle on a consolidated basis, management first assesses company-level controls (全社的な内部統制) that materially affect consolidated financial reporting as a whole, then, based on the result, process-level controls (業務プロセスに係る内部統制) (standard, II.3). Controls over outsourced work are within scope (standard, II.2).
  • Setting the scope: management sets a reasonable scope by weighing quantitative and qualitative effects, and records how and why (standard, II.2). The implementation guidance gives examples: where company-level controls are assessed as good, significant business locations covering roughly two-thirds of consolidated net sales or a similar measure; and consolidated subsidiaries outside the top 95% of net sales may be treated as insignificant and left out. Both are only examples and must not be applied mechanically.
  • Fixed by year-end counts as effective: a material weakness found during the assessment and fixed by the fiscal year-end allows controls to be judged effective; remediation after year-end can go in the supplementary information (standard, II.3).

What the report says: four possible conclusions

The report has four parts (standard, II.4): design and operation; the scope, date and procedures of the assessment; the conclusion; and supplementary information (付記事項). The scope section should give the reasons for the choices made, such as the measure and share used to select significant business locations. There are only four possible conclusions:

ConclusionAlso stated
Internal control is effective (有効である)Nothing further
Some assessment procedures could not be performed, but internal control is effectiveThe procedures not performed and why (for example, a company acquired in the second half of the year could not be assessed in time)
There is a material weakness and internal control is not effective (有効でない)What the weakness is and why it has not been remediated
Significant assessment procedures could not be performed, so no conclusion can be given (評価結果を表明できない)The procedures not performed and why

The supplementary information covers three items: subsequent events with a material effect on the assessment; remediation carried out after year-end; and, where a material weakness was reported the previous year, the status of its remediation.

The internal control audit and the three-year exemption for new listings

A listed company's internal control report must be audited by a certified public accountant or audit firm with no special interest in the company (FIEA Article 193-2(2)). Under the standard, the audit is performed by the financial statement auditor, who forms an opinion on whether the report fairly presents the result of the assessment in all material respects; the audit report is in principle prepared together with the audit report on the financial statements (Internal Control Ordinance Article 7).

OpinionWhen
Unqualified (無限定適正意見)The report is fairly presented in all material respects
Qualified (限定付適正意見)Something in the scope, procedures or conclusion is inappropriate, or the auditor could not perform key procedures, and the effect is material but does not extend to the report as a whole
Adverse (不適正意見)The problems are so material that the report as a whole is misstated
Disclaimer (意見を表明しない)The auditor could not perform key procedures or similar and has no basis for an opinion on the report as a whole

"Internal control is not effective" is management's conclusion; "adverse" is the auditor's opinion on the report. A report that discloses a material weakness can still be found fairly presented, as long as that disclosure is itself accurate. The audit report must then add a paragraph on the weakness and its effect on the financial statement audit, and mention that conclusion within the opinion (standard, III; Internal Control Ordinance Article 6(6) and (7)).

New listings: reports filed within three years of the day a company first became an issuer of listed shares or similar securities (or, if that day falls within the first three months of a fiscal year, the day three months after the year began) need not be audited; the report itself must still be filed (FIEA Article 193-2(2)(iv); Enforcement Order Article 35-3). The exemption does not apply if, in the (consolidated) balance sheet for the fiscal year before the one containing that day, share capital was ¥10 billion or more or total liabilities were ¥100 billion or more (Internal Control Ordinance Article 10-2).

Amendments and penalties

An internal control report can be amended (FIEA Article 24-4-5). The amendment gives the filing date of the original, the reason, and what is amended and how. Where a report that said controls were effective is amended to state a material weakness, the reason must cover what the weakness is, the remediation and how far it has gone, how the conclusion came to be amended, and why the original did not mention it (Internal Control Ordinance Article 11-2).

  • Criminal penalties: failing to file a report, or filing one with a false statement on a material matter, is punishable by imprisonment of up to five years, a fine of up to ¥5 million, or both (FIEA Article 197-2(1)(v) and (vi)); a company can also be fined up to ¥500 million (Article 207(1)(ii)).
  • Civil liability: for a false statement on, or omission of, a material matter, Article 22 applies with the necessary changes, making officers in office at the time of filing and others liable for damages to people who acquired or disposed of the company's securities without knowing of it (Article 24-4-6).

TSE disclosure and mandatory quarterly reviews

  • A report stating a weakness (Securities Listing Regulations Rule 402(1)(am)): a company that decides to file a report, or an amendment, stating a material weakness or that no conclusion can be given must disclose immediately what the weakness is, why it was not fixed by the fiscal year-end, and its remediation policy and plans. The TSE explains this release will normally come at about the same time as the filing.
  • Audit opinion (Rule 402(2)(v-2)): when the internal control audit report gives an adverse opinion or a disclaimer, the company must disclose immediately the content of the audit report, the type of opinion on the financial statements, and its next steps.
  • Quarterly reviews become mandatory: an auditor's review of the quarterly financial statements attached to first- and third-quarter earnings releases is in principle voluntary. If the latest internal control report states a material weakness, or the latest internal control audit opinion is not unqualified (there are other conditions too), later first- and third-quarter releases must carry a review report; the requirement lifts once a later annual securities report and internal control report meet none of the conditions (Enforcement Rules for Securities Listing Regulations Rule 405(2)).

The other internal control: the Companies Act system

The Companies Act has its own internal control: the board may not delegate to individual directors the decision on setting up systems to ensure that directors act in compliance with laws and the articles, and that the business of the company and its corporate group is properly conducted, and the board of a large company must make that decision (Companies Act Article 362(4)(vi) and (5)). The TSE requires domestic listed companies to build and run this system properly, and takes measures such as requiring an improvement report (改善報告書) where it finds flaws it cannot overlook (Listing Regulations Rule 439). This system covers the conduct of the business as a whole; the internal control report assesses only financial reporting. A TDnet notice revising the 内部統制システム構築の基本方針 (basic policy on building the internal control system) belongs to the Companies Act side.

The 2023 revision, applying to fiscal years beginning on or after April 1, 2024

On April 7, 2023, the Business Accounting Council published its opinion revising the standard and the implementation guidance, applying to fiscal years beginning on or after April 1, 2024; for March year-end companies, from the year ending March 2025. The accompanying amendment to the Internal Control Ordinance (Cabinet Office Ordinance No. 57 of 2023) also took effect, in the main, on April 1, 2024. The main changes:

  • Framework: one objective changed from reliable financial reporting to reliable reporting, including non-financial information, while the purpose of the FIEA system stays the same; risk assessment must consider fraud; the IT component now covers outsourcing and information security.
  • Scope: the examples of "roughly two-thirds of net sales or similar" and "the three accounts of sales, receivables and inventory" must not be applied mechanically; a material weakness found outside the scope brings that area into scope, at least for the accounting period that includes the time it was found.
  • Report and amendments: the reasons for scope choices should be given; the supplementary information now includes the status of remediating the previous year's weaknesses; amendments should disclose the specific circumstances and reasons.

The opinion says the Council will consider how to treat the two-thirds and three-account examples, including phasing them out. When this page was checked, the FSA's page for the Council's internal control committee listed December 8, 2022 as its most recent meeting.

Disclosures to look for on TDnet

Title or disclosure itemMeaning
財務報告に係る内部統制の開示すべき重要な不備に関するお知らせA report stating a material weakness is being filed, or a report is being amended to state one (Listing Regulations Rule 402(1)(am))
内部統制報告書の訂正報告書の提出に関するお知らせAn amendment to an internal control report is being filed
過年度の内部統制報告書の訂正報告書の提出及び財務報告に係る内部統制の開示すべき重要な不備に関するお知らせPast years' conclusions are amended to state a material weakness
内部統制監査報告書における不適正意見 / 意見不表明Disclosure of the internal control audit opinion (Rule 402(2)(v-2))
内部統制システム構築の基本方針 の一部改定A change to the Companies Act internal control policy, not the internal control report

Kabuto's earnings stories are under Earnings, each linked to the TDnet original. For the annual securities report see Japan annual securities reports, for going-concern notes see Japan going concern notes, and for the types of disclosure see How Japan's timely disclosure works.


Sources